Abdulmutallib Is Already Talking

So I’m reading about the electronic backtrail of Mr. Abdulmutallab, who attempted to blow up an airplane with a bomb stuffed in his underwear, and found this at the very end:

Still, some of Farouk1986′s writings offer a hopeful tone. He writes about expecting to get over his loneliness when he attends university classes and joins local Islamic groups. He discusses television and soccer, but at one point gets upset after another person posts a sarcastic remark about soccer loyalties.

“I had butterflies going through my stomach reading that,”Farouk1986 wrote. “I acted hypocritically? May Allah forgive me for that. I’m very sorry. Now i feel all bad. Maybe its time to say bye bye to this thread. I’m sorry if i offended anyone. Please all should forgive me.” (Emphasis mine)

Hypersensitivity + isolation + maladaptation to globalization + sexual repression = vulnerability to indoctrination. Abdulmutallab is the poster child for terror recruitment. Which brings me to this item:

(CNN) — The man who allegedly lit an explosive on board a U.S.-bound international flight deserves none of the constitutional protections afforded American citizens, a former top Bush administration official said Monday.

Tom Ridge, who served as secretary of the Department of Homeland Security from 2003 to 2005, made the comments on CNN’s “Larry King Live.”

“I take a look at this individual who has been charged criminally, does that mean he gets his Miranda warnings? The only information we get is if he volunteers it?” Ridge said. “He’s not a citizen of this country. He’s a terrorist, and I don’t think he deserves the full range of protections of our criminal justice system embodied in the Constitution of the United States.”

Right! Torture ought to get the information out of him! Except that Abdulmutallab is already talking. In fact, he’s singing like a bird:

Abdulmutallab claimed to have been instructed by al-Qaida to detonate the plane over U.S. soil, said a U.S. law enforcement official. But others cautioned that such claims could not be verified immediately. Another official said the U.S. had known for at least two years that that the Mutallab could have had terrorist ties and was on a list that includes people with known or suspected ties to a terrorist organization.

So he’s freely giving details of the plot and he’s obviously incompetent in the whole blowing-up things department, but we’re supposed to, what, send him to Gitmo? It doesn’t make a damn bit of sense. But then, when it comes to terrorism the last eight years haven’t made any sense. Back to CNN:

Ridge also said he was “not surprised” about reports that two former detainees in the detention center at the U.S. Naval Base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, had joined up with the group that claimed responsibility for Umar Farouk AbdulMutallab’s failed terrorist attack.

“It’s a symptom of a larger challenge that this country has, and that’s how do you adjudicate these individuals that we pick up from these places and make a determination if they should be incarcerated for a long time, if not permanently,” he said.

Right! Because harshness works SO WELL. The men in that Yemeni al-Qaeda video claiming responsibility for Abdulmutallab’s attack were released to Saudi Arabia in 2007 after being held in Gitmo for more than five years of useless, stupid torture. Do you think they were maybe radicalized by the experience just a tiny little bit?

Here’s what you do with Abdulmutallab: you put him in a jail cell. A regular, old-fashioned one. you question him. You try him and convict him for the actual crime he has actually committed. Then you leave him to rot in prison for as long as the sentence lasts. When his sentence is finished, you deport him.

You treat him according to the laws, because the laws are what makes us America. You don’t throw out the laws and make up new ones in secret just because you’re afraid. And instead of demonizing him, you see him for what he actually is: a frustrated, lonely young man full of guilt at his good fortune who is now only too happy to talk because he’s the center of attention.

About Matt Osborne

Veteran blogging the culture wars from Alabama. Video journalist, mash-up artist, aspiring novelist, and metalhead. Expect bunnies, geekery, dark humor, and snarky empirical analysis to annoy idealists of all stripes. You can follow me on Twitter, but be ready 'cause it might get loud.
This entry was posted in Tom Ridge, Underwear Bomber, fear of terrorism, terrorism. Bookmark the permalink.
  • IrishGirl_AZ

    A one-way ticket from Amsterdam to Detroit: $900

    A PETN bomb from Al Qaeda: Free

    A second degree burn on your scrotum and no lives lost: Priceless

  • mary b

    great, logical post. it should go viral.

  • Joe Troll

    Kids, this misguided youth made a mistake, and thought that his people in Turdistan would honor his name as a great martyr for a long, long, time. His daddy was unable to steer his courageous son away from such a deed. The U.S. government knows that the joys of diversity can be tainted by the evils of "racial-profiling" and un-PC thinking – so they pretented to ignore any warning signs that this innocent lad could blow up a plane. Yes, my children, this justifies the detention and harrassment of little old ladies and WW2 vets at security check-points. Besides, this country could use more people that are different from these regular, dull types of people. You know, like people from very primitive non-European places that basically hate everybody not like them.

  • Matt Osborne

    Joe Troll, profiling doesn't work. Security experts say it doesn't work. Even El Al says it doesn't work.

    Maybe, just maybe, it doesn't work? No, too complicated for trolls. Easier to imagine a complex web of conspiracy aimed at installing global socialism.

  • Joe Troll

    Abdulmethlab was, in a way, "profiled" as being a potential…terrorist by the CIA. Makes one wonder what Mr. Obama knows that he isn't telling the sheep…uh, I mean the American people. Infidels we may be, but Christmas Day is a bad time to blow up planes. No 72 virgins for this reprobate. Three days passed before Barky came out and said a few words about the Burning Man. The guy plays more golf than Willie Nelson…maybe even O.J. Yep, now it'll be flashlights and rubber gloves time when regular Americans decide to venture out in the good ol' USA. "Chapstick??…uhh, come this way and keep your hands where we can see them, Mrs. Smith…we need more officers here now." Is a Rotary Club pin a potential weapon? At least Rachel Maddow will soothe us with smiles and pet pictures while Rome burns. And then there's IrishGirl – now here's a gal that can take a bad situation and come up with some great humor!

  • Matt Osborne

    Joe, Bush waited six days before saying the first word about Richard Reid. He set records for presidential vacation time.

    Your entire shtick is an act of projection, and it's getting really tiresome.