The William Talley Burn Notice: Final Update

Picture via the Tennessean. The following update has been added to The William Talley Burn Notice:

Bill Talley, a former health-care executive turned social media personality, will serve one year in prison and eight years’ probation for possessing hundreds of child pornography files.

The sentencing on Wednesday resolves charges that Talley has been fighting the past eight years. He appealed all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court to have evidence in the state’s case against him suppressed — a request the high court rejected.

That is how Bobby Allyn opened his front page article in the Tennessean last Thursday. He ended it by quoting the prosecutor, Deborah Housel, who wants Talley off of Twitter: “He’s prohibited from being around minors, so just think about it.” Indeed.

Talley’s case had earned the negative attention of anti-pedophile activists, and anger over his relatively light sentence is being channeled into a grassroots campaign to ban pedophiles from Twitter. The outrage is fueled by Talley’s attempt to use his Twitter following as proof of his importance as a community leader in order to argue for a lighter sentence.

Yes: @Political_Bill tried to get out of prison by way of Twitter. His attorney would not have introduced the topic at the hearing without Talley’s instruction. This was the objective Talley had in mind as he shmoozed up to liberal Twitter users and their projects. But because activists had shared Talley’s tweets with Ms. Housel, she was able to rebut him with his own words. His plan failed.

In fact, the episode snapped whatever suspension of disbelief still existed at that point. Talley’s defense is one long persecution narrative: police entered his condominium illegally, police planted evidence, police do not understand computers. When Detective Chad Gish testified to credit card receipts found for the videos, including one of a three year-old girl being raped, Talley dismissed it as a misconstrued case of phishing and identity theft against him.

You see, William Talley is always the “real” victim. Nothing is ever his fault; he has never committed any crime; everyone is simply out to get him.

Talley possessed thousands of pornographic images and videos of children when he was arrested in 2005. The items were found in a folder on Talley’s computer desktop, on the CDs in his office safe, and printed out and tucked into his briefcase. Altogether, more than 100 children were identified in the collection, 59 of whom have been identified by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Detective Gish put over three hundred hours of work into disproving Talley’s elaborate contention that malware was responsible for images and videos popping up uninvited; Talley maintained that he had to save, print, and keep all that material so he could block it from his computers…later.

He was too busy to do it right away, which is why the date/time stamps on the printed filth in his briefcase were up to two years old, but Talley was conscientiously keeping it all filed away in order to get rid of it eventually. Because he was so “repulsed.” See how that works?

Talley, who claims to be a member of MENSA, the “High IQ Society,” and who cultivated the image of a wise elder progressive on Twitter for five years, claimed ignorance that child pornography was illegal. At the time of his arrest, he also admitted to giving friends prescription pills in exchange for money, but did not consider it “selling” controlled substances. In her closing, Ms. Housel quoted a psychosexual report already entered into evidence: William Talley “presents as one to whom the rules do not apply.” He is unique and faultless and great, and the rest of us just don’t get it.

Tweeting from a motel room on Murfreesboro Road, Talley had people believing his phantom ventures were successful businesses. In fact, Talley is one million dollars in arrears with the IRS, having closed his home healthcare business years ago. Here again he claims victimhood: Medicare and the economy, not his battered reputation in Nashville, were responsible for declining revenue.

But the activists who exposed and hounded William Talley held a special, new place in his victimology. A “Twitter lynch mob” has been telling horrible lies about him “because they don’t like our politics,” Talley said, smiling smugly at me.

Our politics — as if Talley defines the liberal brand on Twitter.

Talley has a fan club on the social network that includes core members of Unite Blue, a controversial liberal counterpart to TGDN on the right side of the Twitterverse. Two of his sock puppet accounts, @7serf7 and @politaire, both actively conversed with users who made a great show of unfollowing @Political_Bill. On Tuesday, @7serf7 and @politaire indicated they may be “taking time off” from Twitter; the next day, the accounts were alternately protected or tweeting with new voices.

At this time, Steven Hatlestad, a key figure in the doxing and harassment activity that characterized the flame war over William Talley, appears to be running @politaire; Aurora Grajeda aka @cihuamexica was clearly tweeting through @7serf7. Had the accounts gone quiet with Talley in prison, both people would be exposed for their cooperative reputational defense of a pedophile who enjoys watching the rape of three year old children. As it is, they have done themselves no favors by taking over Talley’s accounts.

The “Cauldron of Stupid,” as Talley’s supporters have become known, has at least stopped making empty legal threats in the face of an actual court decision. Judge Watkins clearly did not believe Talley’s story. Credit card receipts for “hardcore porn, all models guaranteed under 14″ were not evidence of a conspiracy against William Talley, but proof that he belongs in prison. His Twitter accounts were not a mitigating factor for him. The rules would apply to him. While the statutes of 2005 allowed Talley’s entire sentence to be served on probation, a term of confinement was in order.

And then it was over, and I was free to tell Twitter.

Talley’s main @Political_Bill account is still followed by thousands of people five days later, though the numbers are steadily declining. Many people are asking Twitter to delete Talley’s accounts — all of them, even the ones being used by his friends now. They represent a monstrous lie; William Talley’s ego was the only thing about them that was ever real.

If you would like to contact Twitter about William Talley’s accounts, the email address is cp@twitter.com and the accounts are listed below:

  • @Political_Bill
  • @Healthcare_Bill
  • @Strategic_Bill
  • @Sleeping_Bill
  • @politaire
  • @7serf7

A final slideshow: Direct Messages from William Talley. As you can see, he has been waging a one-man disinformation campaign in the back channel.

Posted in crime, Twitter, Twitteratti | Tagged , , , , , , , | 86 Comments

William Talley Sentenced To Prison

billtalleyWilliam Talley aka @Political_Bill on Twitter was sentenced to one year in prison and eight years of probation for possession of child pornography. My tweets reporting the decision are included in a Chirpstory below. Bobby Allyn has also written an excellent piece for tomorrow’s Tennessean. I will have more to say tomorrow. Right now I am recovering from what I had to listen to.

Posted in crime | 95 Comments

What We Talk About When We Talk About Drones

So on Thursday, May 23rd 2013, President Obama made this speech.

It’s a good speech. I agree with quite a lot of it (by no means all of it.) But it’s not really fair to say that it’s reignited the drone debate – the debate has been steadily building for the last four years, and we have that debate to thank for the culmination of events that led to this speech. It’s not going away – technology never does -  so we’re all going to be debating the usage of drones for the rest of our lives. [1] So I figured I’d weigh in. Continue reading

Posted in Drones, Obama's Speeches, Obama's Wars, war on terror | 86 Comments

Ken White Knows Who The Real Bullies Are

kenpopehatpix1

Los Angeles Deputy DA John Patrick Frey aka @Patterico posted unredacted documents (.PDF) at his blog revealing Nadia Naffe’s personal and medical information, then treated Twitter as his courtroom to cross-examine her (.PDF). As a result, her credit was ruined by identity thieves and her hiring prospects were dimmed by Google results. Frey did this in retaliation for Naffe blowing a whistle on the illegal and unethical activities of his friend James O’Keefe after he tried to rape her. Naffe has been trying to sue Frey ever since. Recently a federal appeals court overrode a lower court’s dismissal, meaning that Naffe’s case against Frey will continue for at least a year. She has also succeeded in getting the California Bar Association’s Audit and Review Unit to examine Mr. Frey’s activities, which may lead to his being disbarred.

Pat Frey has enjoyed the pro bono counsel of Mr. Ken White of Popehat.com during all these legal proceedings. Recently, White wrote a post bemoaning the overabundance of anti-bullying initiatives online and in American discourse. He posits that the word “bully” has been rendered meaningless, and politics over-personalized, by too many complaints about bullying:

But perhaps most of all, I don’t like the overuse of “bullying” because it diminishes and degrades the word for petty political purposes to the detriment of actual victims of real bullying. The meretricious overuse of the term “bullying” threatens to degrade it to the point where efforts against real bullying are not taken seriously and are tarred with the same brush of self-serving partisanship.

Remember, one year ago Ken White responded to publicity about Ali Akbar’s criminal record and shady nonprofits by denouncing it as censorship meant to “chill free speech” — basically, White called liberals bullies for writing about Akbar’s recent and ongoing criminality. But White simultaneously insisted that Brett Kimberlin’s decades-old criminal record somehow proved the existence of a sinister liberal conspiracy to bully the poor, misunderstood Breitbart goon squad.

Titled “Bully” Means Just What I Want It To Mean, White’s post would sit better with me if he could recognize a limit somewhere. Does Frey doxing and defaming Ms. Naffe on social media under the implied imprimatur of his office constitute bullying, or not? Because if it does, then he should recognize it for what it is and recuse himself. If Frey’s behavior does not constitute bullying, then the word has no meaning at all for Mr. White, and he should stop accusing unspecified people of devaluing the word.

Given his record, I am not holding my breath while I wait for consistentency.

Posted in Blogging Derangement Syndrome, Kulturkampf | Tagged , , , , , , , | 97 Comments

Not Your Personal Army: How Unite Blue Ignited A War With Anonymous And Then Tried To Blame Their Critics

notyourpersonalarmy

The Anonymous hacktivist collective likes to say they are Not Your Personal Army (NYPA), meaning they do not care about your petty dramas and issues and will not respond to attempted incitement. Politically, Anons tend to fall into the libertarian-progressive space on issues such as internet freedom and equality, but Anons’ causes are mostly not political. A substantial affinity group of anti-pedophile Anons has been carrying out social media action with detached efficiency for years. Having first come to public attention with its awareness and protest campaign against Scientology, “The Hive” is clearly not afraid to make enemies, but it is choosy about them.

Unite Blue is Zach Green’s personal Twitter army, born in a state of hashtag war with uber-conservative #TGDN. For a founding mythology, the Unite Blue website presents a curious permutation of right wing Twitter conspiracy memes about Twitter’s spamblocking algorithm. Unite Blue uses operant conditioning to encourage reactionary behavior; for example, Unite Blue can tell you if your tweets are 97, 98, or 99% “progressive” according to Zach Green’s formula. Team Followback with all of your sock puppet accounts is actively encouraged. From the very beginning, Unite Blue has been built for “Twitter war.”

Perhaps that need for conflict explains why the Unite Blue “community” has landed in a Twitter flame war with Anonymous over a pedophile named William Talley. As a result of misplaced solidarity among a small group of highly-motivated, if not ably-guided Unite Blue members, Zach Green’s personal army has sparked conflict with Anonymous for weeks. The matter reached critical mass last Sunday when a prominent Unite Blue troll named Steven Hatlestad published a YouTube video that foolishly tried to tell Anons their business, violating the NYPA principle and prompting escalation by the collective.

A clique of Unite Blue enthusiasts — dubbed “#CauldronOfStupid” by one witty observer — rallied in solidarity over Mr. Talley, who plead guilty to possession of child pornography in February and then accepted a position on the board of Unite Blue. He was later outed by an Anon and Unite Blue critic named Trina Cuppett. Zach Green removed Talley from the board, but the very next day the “Cauldron” doxed Cuppett in retaliation.

Steven Hadlestad has become something of an enforcer for Unite Blue. He used fake “Anon” accounts to spread an attack blog containing fabrications, libel, and information about Cuppett’s family members. While some observers tried to stop the angry mob, the Cauldron of Stupid used Hatlestad’s attack blog to avenge themselves on Cuppett. Many of the same people who gleefully took part then are now wailing at the unfairness of Anons naming and shaming them in like manner for their support of William Talley.

Hatlestad’s video is included below in a slideshow detailing how this Twitter conflict began:

Absurdly, Hadlestad’s video flashes the Twitter avatar of @Shoq over the word “puppets” as well as “bullying and intimidation.” Talley was broadcasting this theme weeks ago, and his Twitter circle gladly repeats it. But @Shoq is not the commander of Anonymous. This gambit has succeeded in getting many obsessive @Shoq-trolls to become pedophilia apologists, but of course Anonymous saw right through the chaff.

Nor was the collective swayed when Janeal Eller @SDzzz tweeted Anon accounts to try and convince them that @OpTrollBill was Trina Cuppett, or that they were lying, “fake” Anons. In fact, @OpTrollBill is an experienced social media activist with years of law enforcement contacts from finding and stinging sexual predators. He is a dedicated volunteer. So is Trina, who canvassed Twitter last year to help Anne Onymous publicize his video of Mitt Romney’s “47 percent” remarks.

For the last few weeks, the Anons have been speaking out on Twitter to convince Talley’s Unite Blue “family” to disown him. Some did so belatedly, but the Cauldron has developed a grudge about it. They insist the Anons are covertly attacking Unite Blue, and that it is somehow a Twitter cat’s doing, and that I am somehow involved. The Cauldron maintained friendly relations with Talley, insisting for weeks that the public documents about William Talley are fake. They reject your reality and substitute their own.

Continue reading

Posted in astroturf politics, progressives, Twitter | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 118 Comments

Moments Brought To You By #StopRush: Limbaugh’s New Contract

limbaugh

Even after admitting that #StopRush has ruined his advertiser base, Rush Limbaugh is deflecting blame for the resulting losses at Cumulus Media — and says that if the CEO doesn’t stop saying mean things about him costing the company money, why he’ll just disappear in a cloud of butthurt. POLITICO:

The news of Limbaugh’s possible departure comes one day ahead of Cumulus’s Tuesday earnings call, at which Dickey is once again likely to address the impact the Fluke controversy has had on advertising. The source close to the show described Dickey’s remarks about advertising revenue as unjustified, and said such “criticism” of Limbaugh had resulted in the consideration to leave the company.

Nothing is ever Rush Limbaugh’s fault, especially not the words that come out of his mouth. This story, which also ran at the New York Daily News website, is a desperate and futile attempt to puff up his deflated brand image. With his Cumulus contract running out this year, Limbaugh cannot justify his current compensation level when his presence hurts company revenues so badly.

Furthermore, even if Limbaugh changes networks it will not stop thousands of volunteers from switching stations and contacting his new sponsors. #StopRush is happy to help any radio network find out what the CEO of Cumulus Media already knows. And Limbaugh knows that.

Posted in rush limbaugh | 109 Comments

Cancer Truthers Become Kiddie Porn Defenders

hypocrisy1-carousel

After a period of relative silence in the wake of the Cancer Truthers post, several proud participants in the @Shoq Twitter brigade have fallen all over themselves to attack the cat again over The William Talley Burn Notice. Because for some reason, whenever I blog about a man who has pleaded guilty to possession of kiddie porn, it’s all @Shoq’s fault. Because everything is always his fault. That’s how scapegoating works.

These slideshows demonstrate the bizarre double-standards of people so obsessed with hating someone that they defend the indefensible. The first shows how we got here:

Remember when an “#AbusiveFuck” hashtag trended because @Shoq had left his cyber-girlfriend a nasty voicemail eight months before? William Talley is an actual, real, not-imaginary abusive fuck. Every one of the hundreds of pornographic images of children found in his possession was a genuine abuse by an abusive fuck. Many of the people who propelled that hashtag now excuse Talley’s abusive fuckery and say it isn’t something to talk about, or at least something that shouldn’t be discussed on Twitter, because…well, because he isn’t @Shoq. See how that works?

Continue reading

Posted in Burn Notices, Shoq Abuse | Tagged , , , | 67 Comments

Jason Wade Taylor Arrested, Held As “Fugitive From Justice” (UPDATE)

Jason Wade Taylor's mugshot from a 2007 arrest

Jason Wade Taylor’s mugshot from a 2007 arrest

Jason Wade Taylor aka “Randy Hahn” was arrested Saturday afternoon at an off-ramp on Interstate 25 in El Paso County, Colorado after assaulting a woman he had met online. While she did not press charges, he is being held as a fugitive from justice. A hearing will be held today in Colorado Springs and this post will update as further information becomes available.

Taylor is a career criminal who gained notoriety last year after his attempted “long con” of progressive Twitter communities was exposed as a fraud. Enabled by a compliant source, Taylor then engaged in doxing, harassing, and threatening activists in the #stoprush hashtag for several months. His forays into podcasting were all deleted by the host after he made drunken death threats against his victims, and many of his innumerable Twitter accounts have been deleted for Terms of Service violations. Taylor’s most recent return to the microphone involved live, on-air false police reports to harass his former girlfriend and co-host.

Hopefully this latest turn will bring an end to his social media psychopathy. It was only a matter of time before Taylor enacted his violent online fantasies in real life.

UPDATE 1: Taylor is “fugitive” from a felony warrant in Houston. His hearing today was on the bond for his local charge. As a previous bail-jumper with no visible means of support, it is very unlikely he was granted bail. He will have a second hearing, this time for the Texas warrant, on May 7th.

UPDATE 2: Taylor was not granted bond or bail. He will actually have two hearings on the 7th, a disposition hearing at 8:30 am and a pre-trial conference at 1:30 pm. There are indications that his Texas charge is for theft and is being dismissed. This post will update with clarification as soon as possible.

Posted in crime | Tagged , , | 119 Comments

Sad Ending To Wild Baby Bunny Rescue

IMG_2871

My home was briefly blessed by the unexpected arrival of baby wild cottontail bunnies recently. We took in three survivors from a rescued litter and enjoyed six wonderful days with them happily munching clover and grass. We were prepared to release them in another week, but tragedy struck.

The baby bunnies enjoyed being with Bugatti, their “uncle bunny” who lives in the living room. He was fond and protective of them from the moment they arrived. We gave Bugatti cabbage on Friday morning, and we thought we had prevented the babies from being able to get into his cage to eat it with him. But the humans went out to deal with human things, and so learned to their agony that baby rabbits are tragically inventive and adventurous, able to climb gates, squeeze under doors, and team up to defeat obstacles.

By the time we found them, one was already dead and two were dying of gastric bloat from the cabbage. Emergency oral injections of simethicone did not succeed in saving them, and so the Black Rabbit of Inlé took the last one at twilight. All three were buried together in the backyard with much sorrow. Their scampering is missed.

Posted in Obituaries, Rabbits | 128 Comments

This Moment Brought To You By StopRush

10105

Yesterday, Rush Limbaugh admitted that the StopRush movement has virtually destroyed his advertiser base. He could no longer pretend otherwise, as 2,638 advertisers have dumped his show. This morning, David Corn reported at Mother Jones that Republican consultant Frank Luntz told a college crowd this week that Limbaugh’s polarizing influence has become a net negative for the GOP:

As he continued, Luntz … asserted that it had been irresponsible (and bad for the GOP) for right-wing talkers to pontificate about women’s bodies and birth control—an obvious reference to Limbaugh’s attacks last year on Sandra Fluke, a law student invited to testify before Congress on health insurance coverage of contraception.

StopRush set the tone for an election year in which Republican culture warriors consistently put their feet in their mouths with Limbaugh cheerleading all the way. Like an aikido takedown, our success has been possible because of his polarizing influence, not in spite of it. Volunteers share his reactionary rhetoric with advertisers verbatim; almost all companies wind up repelled by his show — and now it is clear even to Frank Luntz that voters also find Limbaugh’s brand of Republican politics repellent.

Partial audio of Luntz’s remark, via MoJo:

Posted in rush limbaugh | 450 Comments

The Margaret Thatcher I Remember

Over at The Daily Banter, Ben Cohen offers a great retrospective of his experiences growing up in Thatcher’s Britain. I visited there in 1984, just two years before culture warriors in Alabama radicalized me into joining the ACLU. I will never forget hearing the same people who wanted to ban my rock and roll telling me that Thatcher and Reagan were heroes of theirs for “restoring conservative values to Western civilization.”

In fact, my observation in 1984 was that the UK had become a police state, and that both Thatcher and Reagan seemed determined to force a nuclear confrontation with the Soviet Union which could hardly advance Western civilization. This popular poster, which I brought home on a postcard after my visit, is a classic take on the way “libertarian” social values and militaristic jingoism worked hand in hand:

gonewiththewindOddly enough, I find myself agreeing with Glenn Greenwald on the proper response to Thatcher hagiography:

There’s something distinctively creepy – in a Roman sort of way - about this mandated ritual that our political leaders must be heralded and consecrated as saints upon death. This is accomplished by this baseless moral precept that it is gauche or worse to balance the gushing praise for them upon death with valid criticisms. There is absolutely nothing wrong with loathing Margaret Thatcher or any other person with political influence and power based upon perceived bad acts, and that doesn’t change simply because they die. If anything, it becomes more compelling to commemorate those bad acts upon death as the only antidote against a society erecting a false and jingoistically self-serving history.

Titling his post “Margaret Thatcher Stole My Milk,” Cohen remembers the disastrous rise of economic inequality and austerity economics during her tenure in office. I remember the sense of decay I felt in 1984: half of London seemed to be covered in scaffolding, but no workers labored to fix the crumbling facades of empire. Argentina’s military junta had been stupid enough to lend Thatcher excuse for adventures, but the “triumph” of the Falklands crisis had not translated into a better Britain.

And at home, right wing authoritarians were having a great time. Goldwater’s brand of extreme conservatism would later manifest in the Gingrich revolution, the Bush administration, and then tea parties, but in 1984 it was already rising with a vengeance from the dark cellar where William F. Buckley had imprisoned it. For some reason, when the epistemic confrontation with Russia that fed their hopes and fears ended, the right wing never changed its behavior. Today, “militant Islam” and “shariah law” are the bogeymen that excuse fascism. The game has not changed.

Destroying the social fabric of America is still an objective in and of itself. It always happens under the shadow of Armageddon, genuine or imaginary, framed as “freedom” from the “oppressive” forces who might wish to share that freedom more equally. Thatcher, who famously said “there is no society, only families,” was mainly successful at atomizing and attacking the society she denied existed while pretending to fly a flag of freedom over it. That is hardly a claim to greatness.

Posted in Austerity, Authoritarianism, Obituaries, United Kingdom | Tagged | 112 Comments